Yankees
Tue, May 12, 10:35 PM
Orioles
Yankees vs Orioles MLB Predictions
Yankees
Baltimore just stole Monday's opener 3-2, and that loss actually makes the Yankees more interesting tonight. New York is still 26-15, scoring 5.2 runs per game while allowing 3.5, and it already beat Baltimore four straight earlier this month by scores of 7-2, 9-4, 11-3, and 12-1. The Orioles are 18-23, just 10-11 at home, and still without Jackson Holliday and Jordan Westburg. DraftKings has the Yankees at -168, meaning you'd risk $168 to win $100, and that's still fair for the better team.
Team Comparison
All Markets
AI Analysis
Baltimore just stole Monday's opener 3-2, and that loss actually makes the Yankees more interesting tonight. New York is still 26-15, scoring 5.2 runs per game while allowing 3.5, and it already beat Baltimore four straight earlier this month by scores of 7-2, 9-4, 11-3, and 12-1. The Orioles are 18-23, just 10-11 at home, and still without Jackson Holliday and Jordan Westburg. DraftKings has the Yankees at -168, meaning you'd risk $168 to win $100, and that's still fair for the better team.
Spread Analysis
New York hasn't made much separation lately, scoring 3.4 runs per game over its last five while Baltimore is allowing 3.4 in that same stretch. That's why Orioles +1.5 makes sense even against the stronger club — you cash if Baltimore wins or loses by one, and recent form points to a tighter game than those early-May blowouts.
Totals Analysis
Will Warren brings a 3.46 ERA into a game where both lineups have cooled off. Baltimore is scoring 2.6 runs per game over its last five and New York 3.4, with those two teams' last five-game samples averaging 6.6 total runs. That lines up with the under.
Every Playoff Pick.
Every Edge
NBA & NHL playoffs are here — our AI model is posting its strongest predictions of the year. Don't miss a single edge.
3-day free trial • Cancel anytime